By Beth Anderson
When I write an historical picture book, I see a movie in my head, and the challenge is bringing that movie to the page. Illustrations will partner in the process, but the words I choose need to create scenes, provide action, and invite the reader into the experience of the main character. To accomplish this, verbs take front and center stage.
LIGHTS come first when you spotlight a character, event, and angle to hook the reader. In this thought process, one vital verb guides me—“take away,” as in, What do I want readers to take away? Then, before I start drafting, I brainstorm words that will support theme, character, topics, and imagery—including a list of verbs. Here are a few examples of "priming the pump” and “filling the bucket."
battle, surrender, resist, fight, give up, unite… [An Inconvenient Alphabet]
sniff, permeate, smell, reek, inhale, investigate, detect… [“Smelly” Kelly and His Super Senses]
Then, it’s time to make the past come alive.
The
CAMERA carries the reader through the telling. If you examine the
“camera” in a story, most often you’ll see it zooms and pulls back—in and out
of scenes, from big picture to character interior. If it’s all close, all
distant, or hangs in the middle, you lose potential drama that propels a reader.
When I learned about close/deep third
person narration, about “proximity” and “psychic distance,” my writing changed.
And the secret was in the verbs. “Head verbs,” or “filter verbs,” add an extra
layer that distances the reader—the narrator layer. Words like heard, saw,
decided, and other “head” actions serve as filters that dilute the
action. To bring the reader INTO the main character’s experience, try eliminating
these verbs and directly connecting the reader to the main character—go from
reporting to experiencing:
She heard a crash. vs. BOOM!
He wondered where it came from. vs. Where did it come from?
This intimacy feels a lot like first
person narration, but by using close third, you have greater access to the
world beyond that one character.
This same concept is also in play when
you move from indirect speech to direct speech. (This choice gets tricky with strict
nonfiction.)
He told her to get off… vs.
“Get off.” [Lizzie Demands a Seat!]
Often a story about a person from the past involves a thought process or dilemmas and can be less than exciting on the page. Dig into the interior conflict. Eliminating head verbs enhances point of view, builds character, and “shows” instead of “tells.” Oddly enough, sometimes cutting verbs helps keep a story active.
ACTION is essential to moving a story forward, engaging young readers, and connecting to history in a meaningful way. Even static elements of a story like “state of being,” context, and setting can benefit from some action.
The first and easiest rule for action
is to dump BE verbs whenever possible. AM, IS, ARE, WAS, and WERE are empty
verbs. THERE WERE and IT WAS beg for replacements, too. Other “verbs of being”
such as SEEM and BECOME often don’t contribute much either.
Franz was a curious child. vs. …Franz’s mind sparked with wonder. [Franz’s Phantasmagorical Machine]
In nonfiction, providing the context readers need to understand the complexities of a different time and place often results in the dreaded information dump. That necessary context impacts character and is integral to conflict, so we need to interlace those ideas.
How do circumstances affect their
actions? For example, in Revolutionary Prudence Wright, taxes and
boycotts must be meaningful without a convoluted explanation.
No British tea! Prudence grew herbs and
made her own Liberty Tea.
No British cloth! She spun flax into
linen and wove homespun fabric.
NO British sugar! She boiled maple sap
into syrup.
No gloves or garments, no ribbons or buttons, no glass or paper! She would do without. Prudence could live with inconvenience and additional work. But she couldn’t live with unjust laws and stolen rights.
Even physical setting can come alive to
enhance character, conflict, imagery, and themes. How would your character
perceive the location? In Smelly Kelly and His Super Senses, the reader
experiences the setting through the character’s super-senses via active,
sensory verbs.
The metropolis hummed. Buildings stretched to the sky. Scents familiar and foreign wafted in the breeze.
Specificity is also golden. Connotation
adds depth. The right verb lets you cut adverbs. Or can ring with theme,
provide a twist, or add humor.
…unwilling to take liberties with their language. [An Inconvenient Alphabet--American Revolution era]
Finally, we all hear the admonition
against passive verbs, where the “actor” is not up front taking responsibility for
the action in a sentence, or not mentioned at all. Passives can hide an
antagonist and minimize conflict. Reframing amps up the telling.
Tad was frustrated by his lessons. vs. Lessons launched him down the hall and out the door. [Tad Lincoln’s Restless Wriggle]
Verbs are “energizers” that power a story. Of course, like the code for pirates in Pirates of the Caribbean, what I share is more what you call guidelines than actual rules. I confess an upcoming release has WAS in the first and last sentences, and more. It has IT WAS, and some head verbs. But sometimes you need a verb to fade back for something else to come forward. Or need a head verb to make a character present. Or just need the simplest way to state an idea. It’s all about choices to make your movie come alive.Give it a Try
Highlight
all verbs in a WIP. Do you see patterns? Overused verbs? BE verbs? Where can
you cut head verbs to zoom in? Where can you interlace action with context? Where
can you add action or more specific verbs? What differences do your new choices
make?
About the Author
Beth Anderson, a former English as a Second Language teacher,
has always marveled at the power of books. With linguistics and reading
degrees, a fascination with language, and a penchant for untold tales, she
strives for accidental learning in the midst of a great story. Beth is the award-winning author of TAD LINCOLN’S RESTLESS WRIGGLE,
“SMELLY” KELLY AND HIS SUPER SENSES, LIZZIE DEMANDS A SEAT!, and AN
INCONVENIENT ALPHABET. She has more historical picture books on the way,
including three more stories of revolution, wonder, and possibility in
2022.
Thank you, Beth. These are great suggestions and apply to all types of writing. Finding the right verb is like discovering a buried treasure!
ReplyDeleteBeth, this is a MASTERCLASS in a post! I'm taking this along with your other comments on my pb bio MS and getting back to work! Thank you for something I'll come back to again and again.
ReplyDeleteWOW! I will refer to this blog again and again. You gave so much information in such a succinct way. THANK YOU!
ReplyDeleteBeth! Wow! I am printing your post to put by my desk! ❤️ Love it. You rock!
ReplyDeleteThis is indeed a masterclass! Thank you:)
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth. I love this post! (And your books.)
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for the examples, Beth! Examples bring advice to life! Examples are GOLD! My brain connects when I'm shown!
ReplyDeleteThank you--looking for head verbs now!
ReplyDeleteWhat a great way to think of a manuscript! "go from reporting to experiencing" stuck out for me, and is something to strive for. Thank you for the great examples, Beth, and much continued success to you!
ReplyDeleteWhat an awesome post. I agree with Jessica: this IS indeed a Masterclass!
ReplyDeleteThank you for providing examples. I'll be combing through some manuscripts today.
ReplyDeleteThank you for these great examples for using the best word choices.
ReplyDeleteWow, what a brilliant post! The clear and succinct examples really drive the message home - I'll definitely be printing this out to refer back to over and over again! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThis post is complete with Lights! Camera! and Action!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth!
You and your books are admired.
Suzy Leopold
Thank you, Beth. Great things to think about. And your examples helped visualize it.
ReplyDeleteGreat tips! Thanks for sharing your wisdom.
ReplyDeleteThank you Beth for the wealth of information!
ReplyDeleteI loved this post, especially the example from Prudence Wright where you provided context. That is one of the hardest things to do without breaking up the flow, cadence, etc. of the story. Very effective!
ReplyDeleteTerrific advice with great examples from your book, Beth!
ReplyDeleteA terrific post. I like the game element of highlighting verbs and focusing on one element only.
ReplyDeleteGreat post. Great guidance for NF writers. Examples of tight, beautiful, compelling NF writing throughout. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteOh Beth, this is such an active article. You hit the nail on the head or Bang! Thank you so much. I'm revising an old tale and active noisy words are popping inside my head. All children's writers, fiction or nonfiction, can use your advice. Thank you!!!
ReplyDeleteWow--great post with wonderful advice! I'm going to share this with my critique partners, as these tips are valuable for writing fiction as well as nonfiction.
ReplyDeleteThank you Beth! I learned a lot of new things about verbs. Your examples are very helpful.
ReplyDeleteComplete new perspective on verbs. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteOh my! Beth, thank you for delving into the subject of verbs. Your tips and examples are in my writer's toolbox. I've got a plethora of notes and ideas.
ReplyDeleteThis is so wonderful. Thank you, Beth. I am excited to dig into my WIP and look at my verbs!
ReplyDeleteFantastic steps to review! Time for Action!
ReplyDeleteExcellent advice and examples. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThis post is great! Thank you, Beth. “Give It a Try” exercise is the jump-start I needed to get through my latest revision.
ReplyDeleteWhat a vibrant, creative post. If THAT doesn’t encourage people to write nonfiction for kids, NOTHING will!
ReplyDeleteGreat post!
Donna L Martin
Story Catcher Publishing
Thank you for pointing out that the secret to proximity is in the verbs. So powerful!
ReplyDeleteGreat advice! I just went to one of my WIP's and made changes. Sounds better already.
ReplyDeleteThank you Beth for this great information.
ReplyDeleteBeth’s blog post was good vs. Beth packed her post with tons of great information! (How did I do?) Learned a lot from this - thank you!
ReplyDeleteThis post bursts with information! I'll be referring back to it often. Thanks so much, Beth
ReplyDeleteSuperb suggestions Beth! I am bookmarking this for future reference!
ReplyDeleteBETH: WOW! I SERIOUSLY feel like I just took an AMAZING writing course--JUST by reading your post! I'm keeping this one on "SPEED DIAL," as well as reading and RESEARCHING your books to continue to INSPIRE my own writing. THANK YOU for the INSPIRATION to use nonfiction writing as a conduit for "accidental learning in the midst of a great story." This is TRULY a GIFT! THANK YOU!!!
ReplyDeleteA huge thank you, Beth! This helped me revise a story I've had shouting at me from the sidelines to pay attention! This post is packed with so much great information!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth! Your clear examples and "head verb" explanation gave me one of those ah-ha moments I cherish.
ReplyDeleteThis is an extremely helpful post. There is so much useful information here that can be directly put to use. Very grateful for this post.
ReplyDeleteI'm printing this out, Beth! Thanks for all the helpful tips! Can't wait for your new books!
ReplyDeleteBeth, thank you for spotlighting verbs! So powerful!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth. Power packed with action and advice.
ReplyDeleteAs a teacher, I've preached the power of action verbs to my students for years. But I never delineated "head" verbs from other action verbs. I love your suggestion to go from "reporting to experiencing." Brilliant!
ReplyDeleteGreat advice and so sharable for both fiction and non-fiction! Will be sharing with my Rate Your Story Community! Thanks for the great lesson!
ReplyDeleteGreat advice, thanks for the examples.
ReplyDeleteBrilliant advice for revising! Thank you!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much, Beth! I'm neck deep in a MG ms right now. But your post still applies.
ReplyDeleteThis is such a fantastic post, Beth! And a timely one, as I spent my afternoon brainstorming verbs for my current WIP. I particularly appreciate your insights about close third POV...this is something I'm working on and paying attention to!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Beth! This is really helpful, as are all your blog posts. I always enjoy them!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth for these insights. You have given me much to ponder as I revise and polish. I look forward to reading your books.
ReplyDeleteSo, so, sooooo helpful! I appreciate the specific examples. Thank you.
ReplyDeleteReading this for my fourth time this month as I revise my story. A golden post! <3
DeleteThanks for pointing out Head Verbs.
ReplyDeleteGreat post! Thank you. I'll now be pulling out all my WIPs and taking another look at each and every verb!!
ReplyDeleteWhat a helpful post loaded with examples I can go back to. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteSo helpful! Looking forward to trying this out! Thank you.
ReplyDeleteWonderful post Beth! I love your sepecific examples and and the focus of treating your MS like a movie. I have just the one to try this out with. Thanks so much.
ReplyDeleteOh my gosh! Saving and sharing far and wide! Thanks Beth!!!
ReplyDeleteThis post is fantastic! Thank you, Beth.
ReplyDeleteOMG! This post is a light bulb moment of finally understanding for me. GREAT examples. Great info.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth! Some days the right guidance comes at the right time. Printing this and keeping it front and center as I write today.
ReplyDeleteWhat a fun to look at pacing. I really like the idea of the camera zooming in and out from the big picture to the deep thoughts of the character.
ReplyDeleteJust coming back to say thank you. Your exercise really helped me with my current WIP.
ReplyDeleteWonderful Lesson!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Beth! Fantastic post!
ReplyDelete